1947 flying disc craze

Ikwipedia

1947 flying disc craze

Reports of unidentified flying objects

Beginning with Kenneth Arnold's June 24, 1947 sighting of nine objects near Mount Rainier, a wave of anomalous aerial-object reports spread across the United States through the summer of 1947 — escalating to at least 800 documented sightings (with some estimates reaching into the thousands), several alleged crash retrievals, and the creation of the first classified military UFO investigation programs. The episode, known as the 1947 flying disc craze, remains one of the most extensively studied UFO waves in modern history, representing the first post-World War II sighting in the United States that garnered nationwide news coverage. Reports peaked on July 7 and largely subsided by July 10, amid numerous hoaxes and misidentifications. The wave occurred against the backdrop of early Cold War tensions, atomic weapons testing at White Sands and Los Alamos, and — in the assessment of crash retrieval researchers — allegedly represented a surge in NHI aerial activity that produced both mass sightings and reportedly recoverable hardware. A Gallup poll in August 1947 found that ninety percent of the American public had heard of the discs — placing the phenomenon "on par with Orson Welles' 'Invasion from Mars', the Loch Ness Monster, and Tom Thumb Golf" — while only half had heard of the Marshall Plan.

If people saw chimaeras back in the days when Greek mythology was being born, it should not be wondered at that people are seeing supersonic discs in this Flash Gordon era.

Denver Post (July 3, 1947)

On July 3, midway through the craze, the Denver Post opined: "Even before Plato, scholars were perplexed by what is real and what isn't...Finally Descartes came along with the theory that 'whatever I apprehend clearly and distinctly is true' and on the basis of such authority it seems unimportant whether people actually saw the discs or only thought they did...If people saw chimaeras back in the days when Greek mythology was being born, it should not be wondered at that people are seeing supersonic discs in this Flash Gordon era."

The craze has been extensively studied within folklore studies and religious studies. Folklorist Howard Henry Peckham argued that "students of folklore have had a rare opportunity to witness the birth and development of a modern myth — the 'flying saucers'." Ted Bloecher, who compiled the most thorough catalogue of the wave, observed that "there were no 'attitudes' about UFOs in June 1947 — there were no preconceptions, no misconceptions, no 'policies' by either press or public, or by any official agencies." Religious studies professor David J. Halperin argued in 2020 that "UFOs are a myth Template:Ndash but myths are real," adding: "The power and fascination of the UFO has nothing to do with space travel or life on other planets. It's about us, our longings and terrors."

Cold War backdrop

The year 1947 was marked by escalating tensions between the Soviet Union and the United States. On March 13, President Harry Truman pledged to contain communist uprisings in Greece and the Turkish straits crisis, articulating what became the Truman Doctrine. On April 16, statesman Bernard Baruch coined the term "Cold War" to describe Soviet–American relations. On April 30, it was reported that Mountain Home Army Air Field would be reactivated for use by the strategic air force as a base for heavy planes. On June 5, Secretary of State George Marshall announced the comprehensive program of American assistance to reindustrialize European nations, over Soviet objections.

The summer of 1947 featured widespread anxiety about atomic energy and the prospect of war. On June 27, retired Supreme Court Justice Owen Roberts warned the US was headed "down the old familiar road of appeasement" towards "an all-out shooting World War III." On June 30, Albert Einstein and fellow scientists warned of a possible atomic war within a decade. On July 1, Representative John Dingell criticized the hosting of German atomic scientists in places like El Paso. In this context of Cold War tensions, many Americans initially attributed flying saucers to unknown military aircraft, possibly of Soviet origin.

Kenneth Arnold sighting (June 24)

Main article:

Kenneth Arnold UFO sighting

1947 flying disc craze is located in the United States

1947 flying disc craze

June 25 -

Kenneth Arnold sighting

near Mount Rainier

On June 24, 1947, private pilot Kenneth Arnold observed a string of nine shiny objects traveling at estimated speeds exceeding 1,200 miles an hour (1,932 km/h) near Mount Rainier, Washington. Arnold described their motion as "like a saucer if you skip it across the water" — a description of flight behavior, not shape — which press coverage converted into the terms "flying saucer" and "flying disc." After refueling, when Arnold landed in Yakima, he described what he had seen to a number of pilot friends, who suggested that maybe he had seen guided missiles or a new airplane being secretly developed by the United States Army. He continued on to an air show in Pendleton, Oregon, and was first interviewed by reporters the following day (June 25) when he visited the offices of the East Oregonian. Any skepticism reporters might have harbored evaporated when they interviewed Arnold at length. Historian Mike Dash assessed Arnold's credibility:

Arnold had the makings of a reliable witness — he was a respected businessman and experienced pilot...and seemed to be neither exaggerating what he had seen, nor adding sensational details. He also gave the impression of being a careful observer...These details impressed the newspapermen who interviewed him and lent credibility to his report.

External audio
Kenneth Arnold radio interview, June 1947 
The following day, Arnold was interviewed on the radio about his sighting and his story was published in afternoon and evening editions of regional papers.[29][30] By June 26, Arnold's story was being widely reported throughout the United States, and the term "flying disc" had entered official military vocabulary.[23][31][32]

The wave builds (June 25–30)

Animation of reports during the flying disc craze

In late June 1947, press began covering reports of flying discs. Arnold's report was the first of many. On June 26, press reported that Byron Savage of Oklahoma City had seen a flying disc about six weeks prior. That same day, Kansas City carpenter W. I. Davenport recalled seeing nine discs while working on a roof the prior Wednesday, and Eugene, Oregon photographer E. H. Sprinkle reported attempting to photograph a formation of nine bright objects in the prior weeks.

Template:Flying disc craze of 1947 map of reports - Jun 26

June 27 brought reports from a housewife in Bremerton, a home-builder in Bellingham, a motorist and family near Wenatchee, a couple from Salem, and a woman from Yakima. On June 28, Arnold publicly criticized the lack of any official investigation, saying: "If I was running the country and someone reported something unusual, I'd certainly want to know more about it." Reports spread throughout the West on June 28, with sightings from a mother and son in Seattle, three airport employees in Cedar City, a family near Boise, an optometrist in El Paso, a dentist in Silver City, and a railroad engineer in Joliet. In Colorado Springs, a crew of seven railway workers told the Denver Post they had seen a disc the prior May. Oklahoma sightings were revealed as handbills released from an airplane, and Washington-based ironworks operator Ray Taro speculated that his foundry's expelled "little aluminum discs" — melted bottlecaps — were responsible.

Template:Flying disc craze of 1947 map of reports - Jun 29 Lt. Col. Harold R. Turner of the White Sands Proving Ground publicly initially speculated the discs "must have been" jet airplanes but later told press that the New Mexico flying disc reports were the result of meteorites. By June 29, one source reported that "These discs, some people suggest, may presage an invasion from Mars." Others suggested the discs were Russian weapons, akin to the incendiary balloons released by the Japanese to cross the Pacific and explode in the US. Speculation suggested that the Navy's experimental Flying Flapjack might be responsible for disc sightings. On June 30, one Oregon preacher suggested that the discs were "the 'advance guard' of universal disaster, heralding the end of the world".

Col. Harold R. Turner, commander of the White Sands Proving Ground, speculated the reports were caused by rockets or meteors.

Official response shifts (July 1–3)

On July 1, Air Force intelligence officer Col. Alfred Kalberer and astronomer Oscar Monnig briefed press to provide reassurance that "we're not being invaded by little platter-like planes from Mars." Monnig described the sightings as "an interesting study in human psychology," recounting that a colleague had predicted after Arnold's report: "Watch the reports pour in now, from all across the country, from people who will imagine they have seen these things, too." That same day, headlines like "Flying Disc Deal 'Solved'" reported that a "flying disc" had been recovered in New Mexico after a local man chased the object until it landed; the object was identified as a "five by eight inch piece of tinfoil." On July 2, Ivy T. Young of San Angelo speculated that his hobby of releasing silvery balloons with his name attached may have been responsible for local disc sightings.

On July 2, Idaho Lt. Governor Donald S. Whitehead revealed publicly that both he and Boise Justice J. M. Lampert had witnessed objects on June 24, the same day as Arnold's sighting. The next day, papers nationwide reported that Lt. Gen. Nathan F. Twining, commander of Wright Field, had announced that Air Materiel Command had opened a probe into the discs, citing a "reputable scientist" who had seen the objects in flight, informing the public that the Army Air Forces "have nothing that would compare to the descriptions of the object," and urging all witnesses to contact Wright Field. Headlines proclaimed "U.S. Stops 'Laughing Off' Stories of Flying Discs," with an Army Air Forces spokesman declaring: "If some foreign power is sending flying discs over the United States, it is our responsibility to know about it and take proper action." Army experts acknowledged they could not explain the discs and had checked research authorities and contractors, none of whom knew anything concrete; they suggested the discs might be the product of a civilian inventor. The Idaho Statesman quoted an unnamed military officer calling the air forces and FBI "complacent" for not pushing a more "vigorous investigation," and noted that Arnold himself had not been contacted by military or FBI about his sighting. The Statesman also quoted FBI special agent W. G. Banister, who reported: "I don't know any more about it than what I read in the newspapers."

Also on July 3, California Highway Patrol Sergeant David Menary and fellow patrolman Walter Castro reported seeing six large metallic discs dive into the San Francisco Bay at high speed; the next day, US Army Major Steve Monroe of the Presidio explained Menary's sighting had been caused by "some of the boys" experimenting with fireworks. A "mystery missle [sic]" was reported in Altadena, and press reported on a potential landing in San Miguel.

Peak reports (July 4–8)

By July 4, reports had spread to eleven states and two Canadian provinces. Headlines declared the Army Air Forces investigation finished — "has not produced enough fact to warrant further investigation" — even as reports continued to accelerate. The San Francisco Chronicle published a letter from local eccentric Ole J. Sneide claiming the discs were "oblate spheroid space ships" absent from Earth "since before the fall of the Roman Empire, when the Great Master left earth for the outer galaxy by fohatic [sic] teleportation." Occultist Meade Layne speculated publicly that the discs were "etheric" in nature — composed of matter that existed between the physical and spiritual planes — suggesting they represented manifestations from alternate dimensions rather than conventional aircraft.[citation needed]

External image
Frank Ryman photograph 
Coast Guard yeoman Frank Ryman in Seattle photographed a disc.[76][77][43] Also on July 4, eight military men were hospitalized with burns after an acid accident at White Sands under Lt. Col. Harold B. Turner.[78]

Flight 105

Main article:

Flight 105 UFO sighting

1947 flying disc craze is located in USA West

Boise

Boise

Flight 105 departed Boise bound for Pendleton.

On the evening of July 4, United Airlines Flight 105 departed Boise, Idaho in a DC-3 bound for Pendleton, Oregon. Boise tower jokingly suggested the crew "be on the lookout for 'flying saucers'." During the flight, the crew observed "four or five 'somethings'" described as "smooth on the bottom and rough appearing on top," one larger than the rest, followed by four additional objects.

Group sightings and the atomic link

On July 5, a group of sixty picnickers in Twin Falls Park reported witnessing thirty-five discs over a twenty-minute period. Police in Portland received reports, some from local law enforcement, with the International News Service reporting that "hundreds of persons" viewed the objects. At Hayden Lake, Idaho, a group of 200 people reportedly watched a disc for thirty minutes. A balloon and a six-pointed, star-shaped tinfoil object were recovered in Pickaway County, Ohio, with witness Sherman Campbell describing the object's distinctive appearance. A wire-service report quoted astronomer Oliver J. Lee of the Dearborn Observatory suggesting the discs were "probably man-made and radio controlled." Physicist Norris Sill, who had served at the Bikini tests, discounted any "plausible connection" between nuclear fission and the sightings. That same day, an Army C-54 transport went missing after departing Bermuda bound for West Palm Beach with six men aboard — a disappearance later incorporated into Bermuda Triangle folklore.

Template:Flying disc craze of 1947 map of reports - Jul 6

During the 1947 craze, flying discs and atomic weaponry became linked in the public consciousness. On July 6, headlines proclaimed "Discs Atom Products, A-Bomb Scientist Says," citing an unnamed nuclear physicist affiliated with Caltech and the Manhattan Project who declared "People are not 'seeing things'" and attributed the discs to experiments in "transmutation of atomic energy" at Muroc Lake, White Sands, Portland, and elsewhere. Papers observed that "the bulk of the flying disc reports have generated in a wide circle" surrounding the Hanford works. Col. F. J. Clarke, commander of Hanford, denied any connection, and atomic scientist Harold Urey and Atomic Energy Commission chair David E. Lilienthal both dismissed the atomic theory as "complete gibberish" and "utter nonsense," with Urey stating that "anyone with elementary knowledge of atomic physics would know this is impossible." The Associated Press reported that fighters had been placed on alert at Muroc and Portland. By July 6, reports had spread to thirty-one states, and Veterans of Foreign Wars national commander Louis E. Starr called for more information, declaring "too little is being told to the people of this country." By July 7, the Los Angeles Times proclaimed: "Flying 'Whatsits' Supplant Weather as No. 1 Topic Anywhere People Meet." Berkeley professor Raymond Thayer Birge reassured the public that the discs "aren't coming from outer space." Army pilots began flying "camera patrols" with eleven planes equipped with telescopic cameras. Civilian pilot Vernon Baird claimed to have seen a "Flying Yo-Yo" over Montana that "came apart like a clamshell" with "the two pieces spiraled down somewhere in the Madison Range"; he described similar objects darting around "like a batch of molecules doing the rumba" — but later admitted the entire story was false. One recovered "disc" proved to be a circular saw blade with tubes and wires attached; another turned out to be locomotive packing washers. An Army weather kite was found on a farm near Granville, Ohio. Truman returned to Washington after a weekend in Charlottesville, driving himself most of the way with police escort.

Hoaxes, pranks, and weather balloons (July 8–10)

Hoaxed discs
Harston with a hoaxed disc from Shreveport[101]
Rev. Joseph Brasky of Grafton, Wisconsin poses with hoax disc
Kemper disc of York, PA[102]
Morfitt disc of Victoria, B.C.[103]

On July 8, Soviet Vice Consul Eugene Tunantzev denied responsibility for the discs, saying "Russia respects the sovereignty of all governments and by no stretch of the imagination would use another country for a proving ground." White House press secretary Charles G. Ross ran a telegram from a professional juggler who reported the "saucers" were things from his act that "got out of hand." Pulitzer Prize-winning journalist Hal Boyle authored a satirical report from inside a flying saucer. Norman Hargrave reported finding an object containing the inscription "Military secret of the United States of America." Orson Welles denied any connection, saying "I scared the shirts off Americans once. That was enough." Thousand-dollar rewards were offered in Los Angeles, Northbrook, Illinois, and Spokane.

By July 8, reports had spread to forty-one states. Science-fiction author and Fortean R. DeWitt Miller compared the craze to 19th-century folklore, speculating the discs were either a new weapon, interplanetary, or "things out of other dimensions of time and space." Radio firebrand Walter Winchell cited DeWitt's book Forgotten Mysteries, highlighting three 19th-century reports he compared to the ongoing craze. Tobacco salesman Lloyd Bennet of Oelwein, Iowa claimed to have found a 6.5-inch diameter disc in his front yard. Frances Adams of Austin similarly recovered a disc which was photographed and publicized. F. G. "Happy" Harston, a Shreveport auto salesman, recovered a sixteen-inch aluminum disc thrown by pranksters.

External image
Albert Weaver photograph[116] 
July 8 also saw the first publication of a flying disc photograph, captured by Albert Weaver of Michigan.[117][118] Press ran a photo of three prominent disc observers — Kenneth Arnold, E. J. Smith, and Ralph Stephens — who had gathered to "compare notes on the 'flying discs'."[119] Reports spread internationally — to Sydney, Johannesburg, and Copenhagen.[4][120][121] Sightings were reported in Saanich, B.C.; in Victoria, a palm-sized disc was photographed and turned over to police by Arthur Morfitt, who said the disc had landed near him.[103] Media reported on rumors that a disc had crashed near Lancaster, setting trees afire; ranch owner Fritz Godde denied the reports.[121] Media compared the craze to the unexplained fireballs reported in May and June 1945 over Japan during the May 23 night raid.[122]

On July 9, airplane inventor Orville Wright argued the reports were "more propaganda for war, to stir up the people and excite them to believe a foreign power has designs on this nation." A triangular object found near Oxford, Ohio by John Strucks was also identified as a radar target used on weather balloons. Dozens of "flying discs" in Richmond, Virginia were revealed to be paper plates released by jokesters from a tall building. A contraption made from pie pans, wires, and radio tubes was found burning on the Clayton County courthouse lawn in Missouri. Al Hixenbaugh of the Louisville Times photographed two objects streaking across the sky. William A. Rhodes photographed an object over Phoenix. Disc reports from Iran were published in US media. With new reports from Kansas, every one of the forty-eight states had now produced disc sightings. Headlines reported: "Army, Navy try to stop rumors of 'Flying Discs'." On July 10, Russell Long of North Hollywood discovered a thirty-inch diameter disc that had struck his house and come to rest in his garden, still smoking with an "acrid, chemical smell." The local fire battalion chief told press: "It looks like someone went to a great deal of trouble for a joke." The disc featured a glass radio tube. FBI chief Richard B. Hood took possession of the disc. In Detroit, Emmett C. Daniels found a disc with "red painted hieroglyphics apparently of oriental origin"; local workers took credit. On July 12, a hoaxed disc was recovered in York, Pennsylvania. The Navy announced it had deliberately released a helium balloon carrying a tinfoil screen over Stone Mountain, Georgia, and that local newspapers had duly received disc reports — as anticipated. Leroy Leach of Dover, Ohio reported discovering a balloon with foil on his farm. A local army recruiter was photographed with a shattered kite and balloon recovered from Bakersfield. In Lima, Ohio, a cardboard disc attached to a balloon was recovered; original witness Kenneth Arnold flatly denied that the objects he saw could have been balloons. The Wisconsin Civil Air Patrol ceased its aerial search for discs. A columnist in Barstow, California, observed that reporting on discs might jeopardize national security: "If these 'flying discs' are enemy experimental dummy bombs or rockets, we have given the enemy valuable information. We have published the exact location, time, etc. This would make excellent data for enemy agents." Walter Winchell speculated that the reports stemmed from secret Navy flying wing aircraft.

Roswell debris (July 8)

Main article:

1947 Roswell incident

At Fort Worth Army Air Field, Major Jesse A. Marcel posing with debris on July 8, 1947

On July 8, 1947, RAAF public information officer Walter Haut issued a press release stating that personnel from the 509th Operations Group had recovered a "flying disc" that had landed on a ranch near Roswell. The following day, the debris was publicly identified as pieces of a weather balloon, with the Roswell Daily Record reporting "large area of bright wreckage made up of rubber strips, tinfoil, a rather tough paper and sticks."

Reports subside (July 9–11)

The Rhodes flying disc photos of Phoenix were published by the Arizona Republic on July 9.

On July 9, the Oakland Tribune announced that reports had dropped off and "it appeared the show is over." The Army and Navy began a campaign to halt the flying disc tales.

Hoaxes and explanations

On July 9, multiple hoaxes and conventional explanations emerged for reported disc sightings. In Richmond, Virginia, dozens of flying discs were revealed to be paper plates released by jokesters from a tall building. In Oxford, Ohio, a triangular object found by John Strucks was identified as a radar target used on weather balloons. At the Clayton County courthouse, a contraption made from pie pans, wires, and radio tubes was found burning on the courthouse lawn.

Continuing reports and milestone

Despite the subsiding trend, some legitimate reports continued on July 9. Louisville Times photographer Al Hixenbaugh photographed two objects streaking across the sky. Reports from Iran were published in U.S. media. By July 9, reports had reached a significant milestone: they had come from all 48 states, with Kansas being the final state to report disc sightings.

Official response

Aviation pioneer Orville Wright dismissed the disc reports as "more propaganda for war, to stir up the people and excite them to believe a foreign power has designs on this nation." Military officials intensified their debunking campaign, with newspaper headlines declaring "Army, Navy try to stop rumors of Flying Discs."

Twin Falls saucer hoax

Main article:

Twin Falls saucer hoax

File:Twin Falls saucer hoax.pngHoaxed saucer from Twin Falls

July 10 incidents

By July 10, the wave had largely subsided, though several significant incidents occurred that day. In North Hollywood, Russell Long reported finding a 30-inch disc with an "acrid chemical smell." When investigated, the fire battalion chief stated there would be "a great deal of trouble for joke" and FBI agent Richard B. Hood became involved in the case.

In Detroit, Emmett C. Daniels discovered a disc with "red painted hieroglyphics apparently of oriental origin," though local workers later took credit for creating it. The Navy conducted a deliberate balloon release over Stone Mountain, Georgia, to generate reports as anticipated for testing purposes.[citation needed]

In Dover, Ohio, Leroy Leach discovered foil balloon debris, while in Bakersfield, California, an Army recruiter was photographed with shattered kite and balloon materials.[citation needed] A cardboard disc was found in Lima, Ohio, prompting Kenneth Arnold to deny that his original sighting could have been balloons.[citation needed]

The Civil Air Patrol in Wisconsin ended their aerial search for discs, while a columnist in Barstow warned of national security implications from the disc reports. Broadcaster Walter Winchell speculated the discs might be secret Navy flying wing aircraft.[citation needed]

Twin Falls saucer hoax

Main article:

Twin Falls saucer hoax

File:Twin Falls saucer hoax.pngHoaxed saucer from Twin Falls

On July 11, press reported recovery of a thirty-inch disc from the yard of a Twin Falls, Idaho home; residents reported hearing a "thud" around 2:30a.m. At 8:20a.m., a next-door neighbor reportedly discovered a "disc" and summoned police. Local police, FBI, and military intelligence from Fort Douglas all responded; multiple officers — two lieutenant colonels, two first lieutenants, and a civilian — flew in to investigate. Authorities "clamped down a lid of secrecy pending the outcome of further investigation" and photographs of the object were confiscated. On July 11, the FBI reported the object had been turned over to the Army. On July 12, it was reported nationally that the disc was a hoax — described as containing radio tubes, electric coils, and wires underneath a Plexiglas dome — and that four teenagers had confessed to creating it. The Twin Falls hoax, with its nationally published image of a bemused army officer holding a disc-like object of mundane construction, has been called the "Coup de Grace of press coverage" on the 1947 wave; in the days following, "press accounts rapidly fell off."

Bloecher recorded: "With scarcely more than a dozen sightings for July 10th, the UFO wave of 1947 had almost completely subsided. Few if any of the reports were carried by the wire services." Bloecher adds: "While interest was high at the time of the sightings, it died out not long after".

Another scholar commented on the brevity of the craze, writing: "The first newspaper accounts preceded a sweep of confirmative storiesTemplate:TspTemplate:MdashTemplate:Tspsome creditable, some doubtful, some proven hoaxes, and innumerable explanationsTemplate:TspTemplate:MdashTemplate:Tspthat caught the nation's attention in a matter of days, and the world inside of three weeks...Yet a hypothetical person not in contact with a medium of communication during the incident, and returning to read an American newspaper after July 20, 1947, would know nothing of the episode which, shortly before, held the world in its grip. The episode was that short, that concentrated, that volatile."

In 1948, the press published a new spate of disc reports and revitalized interest in discs.

Maps of the wave

Main article:

Table of reports during the 1947 flying disc craze

Template:Gallery

Contemporary interpretations

Technological

Initial speculation held that the discs might be technology developed by the Americans or the Soviets.

Col. Harold R. Turner, commander of the White Sands Proving Ground, speculated the reports were caused by rockets or meteors.

On June 28, Army rocket expert Lt. Col. Harold R. Turner of the White Sands Proving Ground speculated that the "discs" were jet airplanes whose "circular exhaust glows brightly when heated and might easily appear to be discs at a distance." By June 29, Turner revised his explanation to suggest the reports were caused by meteorites rather than jets.

The US Navy had experimented with disc-shaped aircraft during World War II. Members of the public speculated the craft were responsible for disc reports, though Navy officials later debunked the theory.

Speculation also pointed to the Navy's experimental "Flying Flapjack", which had been profiled in the May 1947 issue of Mechanix Illustrated. The Navy dismissed that suggestion, noting only one prototype existed and it had never flown outside Connecticut.

On July 3, Lt. Gen. Nathan F. Twining, commander of Wright Field, informed the public that the Army Air Forces "have nothing that would compare to the descriptions of the object." On July 6, racecar builder Leo Bentz speculated the discs were the work of an inventor named George De Bay. Retired general Hap Arnold (no relation to Kenneth Arnold) speculated the discs had either been developed by American scientists or represented foreign technology that had somehow gotten "out of control" of its operators, suggesting a possible malfunction of experimental aircraft.

Balloons, radar reflectors, tinfoil, insulation, and numerous other objects were thought to contribute to the reports.

Others suggested the discs were Russian weapons, akin to the incendiary balloons released by the Japanese. The Los Angeles Examiner received and publicized a letter claiming the discs were atomic-powered Russian planes — a "top-flight atomic scientist" appraised the letter as "not all nonsense," prompting FBI investigators to examine the correspondence for potential intelligence value.

On July 9, the El Paso Times published an editorial calling on the Army to admit the discs were new US technology.

Oliver J. Lee of the Dearborn Observatory offered a technological assessment, speculating that the discs were "probably man-made and radio controlled." Navy scientist Norris Sill, who had participated in the Bikini atomic tests, discounted any connection between the disc reports and nuclear fission experiments.

Behavioral

Dancing plagues of the Middle Ages are thought to have been caused by mass hysteria.

During the 1947 craze, experts in human behavior argued the reports were best explained as a psychological or social phenomenon. The flying disc craze was compared to Scotland's Loch Ness Monster, the panic caused by the Orson Welles broadcast of War of the Worlds, and a sea monster panic caused by a US Armed Forces Radio hoax in Japan.

On July 3, the International News Service suggested a sociological component, arguing that Arnold had "broken the ice" and induced "trained observers to tell stories they had hesitated to relate before in the fear nobody would believe them." As early as July 5, press featured speculation that the disc craze was the result of mass hysteria.

On July 9, psychiatrist Edward Strecker described the reports as the result of "pathological receptiveness," arguing that while initial witnesses "may have seen something, such as the glint of an airplane," subsequent sightings were illusions brought on by hysteria — and that "the emotional state of many persons had been over-active since the first atomic bomb exploded." Winfred Overholser, superintendent of St. Elizabeths Hospital and a nationally renowned psychiatrist, described the reports as a "national hysteria" brought on by post-war anxiety and atomic age fears. Harry A. Steckel, psychiatric consultant to the Veterans Administration, dismissed the hysteria explanation, countering that "mass delusion doesn't account for the consistency of descriptions" and suggesting the discs might be the result of "experiments by unknown government agencies."

An Indianapolis woman was sent to a mental ward after she was discovered "hacking holes in the sidewalk with a hatchet" to "drive the saucers away." The Pittsburgh Sun-Telegraph ran headlines: "If you're seeing those saucers — call the psychiatrist, and quick!" after a Harvard professor proclaimed the mystery was "not a problem for meteorologists or astronomers, but one for psychiatrists."

Behavioral expert John G. Lynn attributed the "wave of saucer hysteria" to widespread anxiety over predictions of atomic war, arguing that psychological stress from nuclear fears contributed to the mass sightings. Other behavioral specialists analyzed specific patterns in group sightings, noting that witnesses in collective observations often corroborated each other's accounts with unusual consistency, challenging simple mass hysteria explanations.[citation needed] The debate between psychiatric experts intensified, with Strecker's pathological receptiveness theory contrasting sharply with Steckel's suggestion that government experiments might be responsible for actual phenomena rather than mere hysteria.

Folklore and academic analysis

Academic experts began analyzing the phenomenon through folklore and anthropological frameworks. R. DeWitt Miller drew comparisons between the 1947 reports and similar mysterious aerial phenomena documented in 19th-century historical accounts, suggesting a recurring cultural pattern.

Broadcaster Walter Winchell referenced a publication called "Forgotten Mysteries" that documented historical parallels to the disc sightings, arguing that similar unexplained aerial phenomena had been reported throughout history but forgotten by successive generations. This historical perspective positioned the 1947 wave not as an unprecedented event, but as part of a recurring pattern of aerial mystery reports.

Academic folklore studies scholars would later characterize the 1947 flying disc craze as the "birth of a modern myth," marking the emergence of contemporary UFO folklore from earlier traditions of sky phenomena reporting.

Scientific methodology discussions

The craze prompted discussions among scientists about proper investigational approaches to anomalous phenomena. Debates emerged between those advocating systematic data collection versus immediate debunking efforts, with some researchers arguing that the rush to explain away reports prevented serious scientific analysis of potentially significant observations.

Interplanetary

See also:

Extraterrestrial hypothesis

Interplanetary invaders, as depicted on the August 1927 cover of Amazing Stories

On June 27, unnamed experts argued that supersonic saucer-shaped aircraft would be "out of this planet." On June 28, headlines joked "No, They're Not Men from Mars." By June 29, one source reported that "these discs, some people suggest, may presage an invasion from Mars."

On July 7, Arnold raised the topic of possible extraterrestrial origins in two wire-service stories. He told the Chicago Times: "If our government knows anything about these devices, the people should be told at once. A lot of people out here are very much disturbed. Some think these things may be from another planet." Arnold noted the objects "were making turns so abruptly in rounding peaks that it would have been impossible for human pilots inside to have survived the pressure." Whoever controlled them, he said, obviously was not trying to hurt anyone. He concluded "they are controlled from elsewhere, regardless of whether it's from Mars, Venus, or our own planet."

On July 9, US Senator Glen H. Taylor of Idaho said he "almost hoped" the discs would turn out to be spaceships from another planet, explaining that "the mere possibility that the spinning circles might be hostile would unify the peoples of earth as nothing else could."

In an Associated Press story from July 19, Arnold reiterated his belief that if the objects were not Army, then they were extraterrestrial.

Biological

In 1923, paranormal author Charles Fort had mused: "It seems no more incredible that up in the seemingly unoccupied sky there should be hosts of living things than that the seeming blank of the ocean should swarm with life."

On July 7, 1947, a fan of Fort's writings named John Philip Bessor became the first modern proponent of the space animal hypothesis when he authored a letter to the Air Force suggesting that the discs might be "animals bearing very little likeness to human beings." In 1949, Bessor wrote to the Saturday Evening Post to suggest that the discs might be "more like octopuses, in mentality, than humans." In April 1949, the Air Force's Project Sign released an essay considering the hypothesis, writing: "the possible existence of some sort of strange extraterrestrial animals has been remotely considered, as many of the objects described acted more like animals than anything else." In October 1954, Alfred Loedding was publicly quoted on his suspicion that the discs "may be a kind of space animal." By 1955, Arnold himself began promoting the theory, suggesting the objects were "sort of like sky jellyfish."

Eschatological

"Death on a Pale Horse", an apocalyptic image from the Book of Revelation, as depicted by 18th-century artist John Hamilton Mortimer

Some members of the public interpreted the reports as signifying the end of the world.

On June 27, Arnold told press he had been contacted by a preacher who insisted the objects were harbingers of Doomsday. On June 30, an Oregon preacher suggested the discs were "the 'advance guard' of universal disaster, heralding the end of the world."

On July 5, press reported on a sixty-seven-year-old gardener who claimed to have watched saucers for about thirty minutes before going to bed, saying: "I thought about waking up some of my neighbors but decided if it meant the end of the world they would be just about as happy sleeping when the world ended." On July 9, deputies in Everett, Idaho took a woman into custody who was marching around a lake, Bible in hand, speaking only of discs and the end of the world; the woman "had never been known to be irrational." In Oshkosh, Wisconsin, a housewife directed press to the Book of Job, explaining "when man becomes too vain and smart, some divine being will send things of various sizes and shapes through the air to confound and confuse man." In Louisiana, Governor Jimmie Davis relayed an explanation: "Saucers are part of the prophecy, something man is supposed to see and not understand. Next the world will know no seasons."

Occult

See also:

Interdimensional hypothesis

Theosophists Annie Besant, Henry Olcott (left) and Charles Leadbeater (right) popularized the mythical "etheric plane".

As early as July 4, the United Press quoted Meade Layne, publisher of an occult magazine, who speculated the discs were "etheric" and claimed to be in telepathic communication with "people in the saucers." Layne claimed: "These visitors are not excarnate humans but are human beings living in their own world. They come with good intent. They have some idea of experimenting with earth life." The prior year, it had been reported that Layne consulted a medium who relayed communications from a "space ship named Careeta" that had come to Earth from an unidentified planet.

Esoteric

Main article:

Shaver Mystery

Nearly a year before the flying disc craze, Amazing Stories featured disc-shaped spacecraft.

Since 1945, the science-fiction magazine Amazing Stories had published claims from Richard Sharpe Shaver that he was in communication with subterranean beings concerned about atomic pollution who piloted disc-shaped craft. In the October 1947 issue, editor Raymond A. Palmer argued the flying disc wave was proof of Shaver's claims. Shaver wrote: "The discs can be a space invasion, a secret new army plane — or a scouting trip by an enemy country...OR, they can be Shaver's space ships, taking off and landing regularly on earth for centuries past... I predict that nothing more will be seen, and the truth of what the strange disc ships really are will never be disclosed to the common people."

Maury Island and the Kelso crash

Main article:

Maury Island incident

Maury Island is located in Washington (state)

Maury Island

Maury Island

Location of Maury Island, Washington

On August 1, a B-25 departing McChord Field bound for Hamilton Field crashed near Kelso, Washington, killing both pilot and co-pilot. The following day, a "mysterious telephone informant with uncannily accurate information" contacted the United Press in Tacoma, claiming the crashed B-25 had been loaded with flying disc fragments and that Kenneth Arnold and Flight 105 pilot E. J. Smith had been "in secret conference" at Tacoma's Hotel Winthrop. General Ned Schramm of the Fourth Air Force publicly acknowledged that the deceased pilots were intelligence officers who had traveled to Tacoma to meet with Arnold, but denied knowledge of any debris onboard the plane, telling press "it was his understanding" that the pilots "were not bringing anything back with them." By August 3, press reported a detailed narrative: Arnold had traveled to Tacoma to investigate claims by Fred Crisman and Harold Dahl, who reported recovering debris dropped by a flying saucer at Maury Island. Army Air Force investigators flew to Tacoma, took possession of the debris, and departed in their B-25 to return to Hamilton Field.

Public awareness

On August 19, Gallup published a poll reporting that ninety percent of the public had heard about flying discs. The survey showed that twenty-nine percent believed the discs were illusions or imaginary, thirty-three percent did not know what they were, and nine percent offered other interpretations, including linking the discs to atomic weapons or the end of the world.

Crash retrievals

The sighting wave coincided with — and, in some analyses, may have precipitated — a series of alleged crash retrievals of purportedly non-human vehicles:

Leonard Stringfield, who compiled seven UFO Crash Retrieval Status Reports between 1978 and 1994, documented dozens of retrieval incidents from the late 1940s onward and became the principal cataloguer of crash retrieval testimony during this era. Researcher Ryan Wood independently catalogued 104 cases, most uncorrelated with Stringfield's collection.

In 1995, the US Government released a report concluding that the Roswell Incident stemmed from a Project MOGUL balloon.

In the 1990s, the General Accounting Office launched an inquiry and directed an internal Air Force investigation. The resulting 1994 report concluded that the material recovered at Roswell in 1947 was likely debris from Project Mogul, a military surveillance program employing classified high-altitude balloons (part of an unclassified New York University project by atmospheric researchers) launched from Alamogordo Army Air Field for monitoring Soviet nuclear testing.

Military response

The wave prompted the creation of the first classified military UFO study programs:

George Knapp argued that this institutional response — born from an inability to intercept, identify, or control the objects — created the conditions for a permanent cover-up: "Nobody wants to admit, if you're a president or chairman of the Joint Chiefs, that there's something flying in our atmosphere and we can't control it."

Twining memo and aftermath

On September 23, 1947, Lt. Gen. Nathan F. Twining issued a memo to Brigadier General George Schulgen of the Army Air Forces, subject line "AMC Opinion Concerning 'Flying Discs'." The memo stated: "The phenomenon reported is something real and not visionary or fictitious." Twining went on to become Chief of Staff of the United States Air Force in 1953 and Joint Chiefs of Staff in 1957.

In 1984, the hoaxed Majestic 12 documents included a memo attributed to Twining; the FBI declared the documents "completely bogus" — an assessment echoed by most ufologists.

Nuclear connection

The geographic concentration of 1947 sightings and crash retrievals around New Mexico's nuclear infrastructure — White Sands, Los Alamos, the Trinity test site, Sandia, and Kirtland — has been interpreted by multiple researchers as evidence of NHI interest in humanity's nuclear weapons capability. The 509th Bomb Group at Roswell Army Air Field, the unit that recovered the Roswell debris, was the world's only atomic bomb-equipped military unit at the time.

Electromagnetic disruption hypothesis

One proposed explanation for why NHI craft crashed during this specific period involves the newly deployed high-powered radar installations surrounding White Sands. The hypothesis — advanced by multiple researchers including Stanton Friedman — holds that concentrated radar emissions may have disrupted the propulsion or navigation systems of craft operating in the area, causing a temporary spike in retrievable wreckage during 1947–1948.

Keyhoe and flying saucer conspiracy theories

Main article:

UFO conspiracy theories

In the decades between the initial debris recovery and the emergence of Roswell theories, flying saucers became synonymous with alien spacecraft in popular culture. In May 1949, journalist Donald Keyhoe of True magazine was tasked with investigating the reports. On December 26, True published Keyhoe's piece, titled "The Flying Saucers Are Real," claiming that elements within the Air Force knew the objects existed and had concluded they were likely "inter-planetary." The article caused a sensation and was expanded into a book of the same name. In 1953, Keyhoe wrote that "Since July, 1952, in a new investigation of the saucers, I have been privileged to cooperate with the Air Force. Because of my present understanding of their very serious problem, and certain dangers inherent in the situation, I have been given information unknown to most Americans." In 1955, Keyhoe accused elements of the United States government of engaging in a conspiracy to cover up knowledge of flying saucers, claiming the existence of a "silence group." Historian Curtis Peebles argued: "The Flying Saucer Conspiracy marked a shift in Keyhoe's belief system. No longer were flying saucers the central theme; that now belonged to the silence group and its coverup." UFO believers would later accuse the government of a "Cosmic Watergate," alleging systematic concealment of extraterrestrial contact. After the John F. Kennedy assassination and the Watergate scandal, trust in the US government declined significantly and acceptance of conspiracy theories became widespread.

Arnold himself detailed his sightings and disc investigations in a 1952 book co-authored with Amazing Stories editor Raymond A. Palmer. He was the Republican nominee in the 1962 Idaho lieutenant gubernatorial election. In 1977, he appeared at a convention curated by Fate Magazine to mark the thirtieth anniversary of the "birth of the modern UFO age."

Occultist Meade Layne founded the "Borderland Sciences Research Associates" and in 1961 self-published The Flying Saucer Mystery and Its Solution, continuing to argue for his "Ether Ship" belief; he came to be seen as an early proponent of the interdimensional hypothesis. Numerous other saucer cults and UFO religions arose in the following years.

Richard Sharpe Shaver continued to promote his underground civilization stories. During the last decades of his life, Shaver devoted himself to "rock books" — stones he believed contained embedded pictures and texts from ancient advanced races. After Shaver's death in 1975, Palmer admitted that "Shaver had spent eight years not in the Cavern World, but in a mental institution" being treated for paranoid schizophrenia.

In February 1978, UFO researcher Stanton Friedman interviewed Jesse Marcel, who had traveled with Roswell debris to Fort Worth. Marcel's statements contradicted those he had made to the press in 1947. In November 1979, Marcel's first filmed interview was featured in a documentary titled "UFO's Are Real," co-written by Friedman. On the TV series In Search of... in 1980, Marcel described the 1947 press conference: "They wanted some comments from me, but I wasn't at liberty to do that. So, all I could do is keep my mouth shut. And General Ramey is the one who told the newsman what it was, and to forget about it. It is nothing more than a weather observation balloon. Of course, we both knew differently." Marcel gave a final interview to HBO's America Undercover which aired in August 1985. Marcel consistently denied the presence of bodies. By the 1990s, Roswell was home to a UFO museum and an annual UFO festival.

Legislative and cultural legacy

The 1947 wave established the vocabulary ("flying saucer," "flying disc," "UFO"), the institutional frameworks (Project Sign, Majestic 12), and the secrecy architecture (compartmentalization, need-to-know, disinformation campaigns) that would define the UFO cover-up for the following seven decades. The National Security Act of 1947, signed into law on July 26, 1947 — weeks after the Roswell retrieval — created the Central Intelligence Agency, the National Security Council, and the unified Department of Defense, providing the bureaucratic infrastructure through which crash retrieval programs would subsequently be concealed.

Roland Barthes, a founding figure of cultural studies, recalled: "The mystery of flying saucers was at first entirely terrestrial: we suspected that the saucers came from the Soviet netherworld, from this world as devoid of clear intentions as another planet." Folklorist Gordon Arnold wrote: "Many aspects of the great flying saucer wave raise questions about human behavior and America's social, cultural, and political inclinations."

Scale of the wave

Between June and August 1947, the number of reported sightings escalated rapidly. By the end of 1952, the United States Air Force had formally collected approximately 3,200 UFO reports, a quarter of which remained classified as "unknowns" after investigation. George Knapp characterized the period as "this gigantic wave" in which "hundreds of sightings" occurred simultaneously with the earliest known crash retrievals, noting that the military had "just come out of World War Two" and was "faced with a new threat that they really don't know what the hell it is." The wave was not confined to New Mexico; sightings were reported across the continental United States, with concentrations near military installations, nuclear facilities, and the Pacific Northwest.

Key scholars

Researchers who have examined the 1947 wave include:

See also

Further reading

Popular

Scholarly

Sources

References

Source ratings:

(Color-coding) (

[1 Wikipedia-grade]

·

[2 Questionable]

·

[3 Reporting/Analysis]

·

[4 Speculative/Hearsay]

·

[5 Ungrounded]

). (To change source ratings,

edit this page

.)

Bibliography

Distant UFO sightings (list) with multiple military witnesses (list)vte
Cases
Battle of Los Angeles · 1947 flying disc craze · 2006 O'Hare International Airport UFO sighting · Calvine UFO · Finnish Air Force UFO sighting · Japan Air Lines Cargo Flight 1628 incident · Mantell UFO incident · USS Theodore Roosevelt UFO incidents
Category (nested under UFO sightings)

Wikipedia This article incorporates material from the Wikipedia article "1947 flying disc craze", as of 2024-12-26, released under the Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 4.0 License.